Mexico mourns after Casino Royale massacre


Dear readers,

Though originally the plan was to wait for AQBlog to publish this piece, I suspect they are dealing with Hurricane Irene in the NYC offices and might have already evacuated. For that reason and that reason alone, I am publishing this article on my personal blog (here) first. I’ll let you know when it goes online at AQBlog.


“Mexico mourns after Casino Royale massacre”

Yesterday Mexico suffered the criminal attack with most civilian casualties in its recent history, as a group of 10-12 armed men entered the two-story ‘Casino Royale’ in the city of Monterrey, doused it with a flammable liquid and threw Molotov cocktails in the first floor. Details are still sketchy as I write these words and the death toll has not yet been established but unofficially the number is above 50, most of them women. The motive behind the attack will probably never be determined, but the local media’s investigative reports point towards non-compliance with a criminal gang that had demanded a cut of the business’ profits in exchange for ‘protection.’

Gruesome as the attack itself was, the reason for the elevated number of victims sadly has more to do with institutionalized corruption than with the criminal act itself. Survivors to this tragedy have testified that other than the main entrance to the establishment (which was blocked by the attackers), four non-labelled service doors were locked and the only supposed emergency exit to the place was fake and had a concrete wall behind it. The amount of suffering and emotions the victims must have felt when they thought they would be able to escape the fire and faced a wall in front of them, is horribly unimaginable.

Casino Royale received its license to operate as a restaurant and betting house in 2007, during the administration of Mayor Adalberto Madero, who in 2011 was officially kicked out of the PAN party for corruption charges and tainting the party’s image (he was later reinstated due to a technicality). Ironically enough, Rodrigo, José Francisco and Ramón Agustín Madero (Adalberto’s cousins) are members of the Administrative Board of the company that owns Casino Royale.

The matter becomes worse when we learn that during 2011 the establishment had already been subject to two other criminal attacks and during neither of the follow-up investigations was the fact that the venue was obviously not up to code, enough to shut it down permanently.

Today, a city and a whole country mourn. Frustration is at an all-time high and is manifesting itself in different ways. On Twitter users heightened their continued demands for Governor Rodrigo Medina to resign. Others called for the two local soccer teams to hold a friendly match in the name of peace and/or for people to wear white in the next match on Saturday. Peace rallies are the current talk of the town and surely at least one march will take place in the near future.

Well-intentioned as these efforts may be, the sad truth is that they will do little to solve the problem. And going after the criminals with guns is a must, but that is fighting the manifestations of the ailment and not the root causes. Calderon’s war on organized crime is palliative at best. The worst criminals behind massacres like Casino Royale do not carry an AK-47. They wear suits, sit behind desks at government buildings and are a part of institutionalized corruption. And we keep them there.

While I can certainly understand the plight for Medina to leave office, the person is only part of a larger system-level problem and changing a system does not occur with one single action, and it does not occur overnight.

The prescription for a real cure seems like a utopian list we’ve heard over and over again: better education, more viable job opportunities, strengthened law enforcement, rule of law, actively combating impunity and corruption, etc. But if we really want to act on our current frustration, I believe there are individual actions that each of us can take in order to start moving in the right direction. I for one, plan to do my part.

On January 5th, I wrote “A New Year’s Resolution for Mexico” for Americas Quarterly. Back then I called for our new year’s resolution as Mexicans to be not exercising any form of corruption. I proposed that we no longer bribe public officials to avoid a speeding ticket. No more tax evasion, no more purchasing pirate products which we now know are part of organized crime’s value chain. No more negligence in our duty to monitor and demand effectiveness from our elected officials and government bureaucrats and no more questionable practices in the companies we work for.

Little by little, with each permissible act of corruption, we have collectively allowed for this tragedy to happen. My new year’s resolution is even more relevant today than it was when it was originally published and I firmly believe it is a small but decisive step toward the system change we need to instil.

My heartfelt condolences for the victims of the Casino Royale tragedy and their families.


5 thoughts on “Mexico mourns after Casino Royale massacre

  1. adriana

    I’m impressed, you’ve put to words the feelings of many! I read you and wish that your words were magic. It is very, very sad to see our city, our people hurting like this and I include myself because before leaving our houses we stop to think ” do I really NEED to go out” every day my children go to school, which they are older and they drive themselves to school, I am not at peace until they call me that they have arrived, and for a while I am at ease, for a while because then they come home and the agony starts on over and over, and every day, and thats the same for my husband, my friends, everybody. I don’t know it’s just a mother hurting.

  2. Federico Sendel

    Great article Arjan. You make a great point regarding the role of corruption in the high number of deaths. It’s likely the perpetrators did not mean for so many to die, but they weren’t counting ( ?) on the ridiculously unsafe characteristics of the building, such as the fake emergency exit.

  3. Bill Monning

    Hola Arjan,
    Thank you for writing and sharing this. Our hearts have been saddened by the news reports of this horrific crime. Your knowledge and analysis revealing the corruption and failure to provide safety exits compound the sense of outrage and sadness.
    Please convey our condolences to all our friends in Monterrey and may this tragedy inspire new levels of civic action and civility as the world condemns such senseless acts of violence wherever they may occur.
    Salud y Paz, Bill Monning, California

  4. Ma. Teresa Salinas de Mtz.

    Hola Arjan:
    Gracias por tomarte el tiempo de escribnir, el sentimiento y el pensamiento de muchos, muchísimos mexicanos que estamos viviendo está triste realidad. Estoy de acuerdo contigo, el cambio que deseamos no va a caer del cielo, tenemos que trabajar cada día, desde lo que nos toca hacer, como madres, padres, ciudadanos comprometidos, profesionistas, trabajadores, etc. etc.
    Me uno contigo en tu propósito de Año Nuevo, queremos soluciones rápidas pero es necesario empezar por lo que está a nuestro alcance, que es nuestro actuar diario. Somo más, muchos más los buenos!
    Tere Salinas de Mtz.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s